Critical Literacy
In order to help students facilitate this type of discussion, Jen Jones-Hello Literacy created these sentence frames in order to help students frame their thoughts, ideas and opinions. They are FREE and you can download them Here.
Theme Statements in Critical Literacy
Critical literacy questions
http://media-cache-ec3.pinimg.com/originals/83/88/d6/8388d69b03559d4cc8dbeca354cacb52.jpg
Good for opinion or fact and going into critical literacy
http://oscarlearnoscarteach.tumblr.com/
Hello Literacy: Informational Literacy Unit - Post Revised
Reading Specialist Blog
http://helloliteracy.blogspot.com.au/2012/02/informational-text-unit.htmlExamples of useful critical literacy forms provided by our Reading Education 530 professor Monica Billen.
This is a record sheet for teacher use during literature circles.
Each child in a literary group will have a job.
One job is the word finder.
This child looks for unknown words in the story
One job is the word finder.
This child looks for unknown words in the story
and completes this chart.
Illustrator, a student draws a specific scene from the story.
The job of the connector is to find a 'connection' between the book and the outside world.
The discussion director creates questions for their group to discuss about their book.
This form is filled out when the book club members meet to discuss the book and do the above mentioned job. It is a Group Meeting Log
This is a Teacher Daily Log that can be used when she observes the groups to see if they are fulfilling the requirements of their jobs.
This is a SAMPLE Teacher Daily Log Form
Articles that I found helpful for reading instruction.
The Impact of Early School
Experiences on Initial Reading
By: Connie Juel
Summary
The research presented in
this article sums up that much of the work teachers have been doing over the
past few decades has left many students reading below basic. This is especially
prevalent in children of lower social economic families. Juel findings
show that children poor reading skills followed them throughout their academic
careers. The best predictor of children that would continue to struggle
in reading would be phonemic awareness. Her study finds that preschool
can narrow these reading gaps.
Vocabulary and knowledge
are huge predictors of later reading comprehension. Children with more
worldly exposures and rich language will have much greater success as readers.
The things schools need to get right in early school years are vocabulary and
word recognition. Again vocabulary of entering first graders predicts
their 11th grade reading comprehension. Moats’s “word poverty”
estimates successful first grader readers have vocabulary knowledge with a
difference of 15,000 words. The research stating that 90% of words in books are
within the same 5,000 words.
The comprehension of the
other 10% of words used are what causes comprehension problems. Teachers
are provided guidelines of which words to select from texts from Beck, McKeown
and Kucan. The words are divide into Tiers 1, 2, and 3. Allowing teachers
to spend time on words that will be more helpful to students in the
future. Again this research brings back the fact word recognition is
important is the access card to reading.
Children with reading
problems suffer self-esteem issues much more in higher grades. First
graders tend to attribute reading problems to effort rather the ability.
As students get older they feel it is their own lack of ability that prevents
them from reading making many stop trying.
The two aspects of phonemic
awareness are that reading fosters it and writing facilitates it. Awareness of
phonological structure seems to be fostered through invented spelling.
Teachers directing this activity with exaggerating gestures and sounds helps
children learn and attach letters to sounds. Juel refers to this as
instruction that makes sense.
Writing systems that employ
syllables as a base for speech representation are easier to learn than one that
works on phoneme level. Sounding out a word using rules and letter sound
associations taught in phonics can create problems because of the mismatch of
how the word is spoken (dialect) and the animal being one the child knows.
(hog, huh, huhaaawwwguh)
Researchers claimed a child
that is armed with phonemic awareness and some basic letter sound
correspondences and has a rich exposure to print and spoken words can teach
themselves to read “self teaching hypothesis”.
Phonics is an umbrella term
that stands for many forms of instruction that links letters and sounds. The
individual classroom teacher makes the difference in learning outcomes, no
matter what the program or curriculum. Of the phonics programs studied the
only true difference revealed was the effectiveness of the classroom teacher.
First are the concerns that
phonic or sounding out words is based on the assumption that children know the
meanings of the words they are decoding. Phonics works only if the sounds
produce a recognizable word. In many cases this untrue and serious
problem. Second concern is spending large amount of time on letter sounds
and less time on developing oral vocabulary and knowledge.
Comments:
This article reveals a
scary truth that is hard for teachers to face. I feel that we all become
teachers to help children learn and make their lives better. Now to
realize that we have been doing things wrong for decades is terrible. It
is difficult to know that first grade can determine to the rest of a child’s
academic career especially now that I teach first grade.
“The things schools
need to get right in early school years are vocabulary and word recognition.”
I am so thankful that
we have begun using Guided Reading this year. Through the leveled text
and the way we work and discuss in our small groups has allowed me a closer
look at how first graders think and perceive things. I am so surprised
everyday at the things they know and don’t know. I feel Guided Reading
will hopefully help children not only be able to decode and read the word but
they will understand what the word means. In each lesson I find my
students are running into different words that they have not been exposed to or
use in a different context. Just last week a child in my J group could
decode and read, “engine” but she did not have a clue they were taking about
the truck’s motor in the story. Engine meant a train to her.
I can relate to all of the
research in this article. I have taught reading in grades 1st through
7th. I have had those children in my class with the academic
low self-esteem that would rather get into trouble rather than read. I am
broken hearted over the research that children rarely overcome their reading
difficulties by third grade. We as teachers are going to have to get our
students reading well by first grade. I have learned so much from these
articles. I have worked very hard over the years to make sure my students
are where they need to be when they leave my class. I feel this Kindergarten
Literacy class has given me so many more tools to help me become more
effective.
In the article it talks
about how reading fosters phonemic awareness and writing facilitates it.
The invented spelling helping students become aware of phonological structure.
Teachers directing this activity with exaggerating gestures and sounds
helps children learn and attach letters to sounds. Juel refers to this as
instruction that makes sense. Juel is right I think about this letting the
children make the connection with exaggerated sounds by the teacher. I
found myself when I taught 6th and 7th grade reading that
when I did a writing assignment and their story needed be spelled correctly and
grammatically correct I would barely get two paragraphs from them. However,
when I removed the grammar and spelling restrictions from their writing I would
get up to two pages. Their stories would be so much more colorful and
in-depth. I enjoyed those papers so much better and so did the students
because they would write and write.
Phonics is an umbrella
term that stands for many forms of instruction that links letters and sounds.
Phonics works only if
the sounds produce a recognizable word.
Schools and teachers are
going to have to start teaching correctly because it is our responsibility and
job to teach children to read. Yes, it is nice to have parent help and
support but just as the research state that is not realistic in most
cases. We are going to have to be more effective developing the their
vocabulary and knowledge along with decoding. The blame for a child’s
failure to read is left with the teachers and the school.
Summary:
Encouraging Young Children’s Language with Stories
McKeown and Beck
Two aspects of oral language: the amount of language
heard in the home and children’s participation in conversational interaction.
Researchers who observed teacher student read aloud
interactions identified talk-surrounding reading as the most valuable aspect of
the activity for enhancing children’s language development
Dickinson and tabors found evidence that preschool
children’s participation in talk about book reading enhances the growth of
children’s literacy skills
Morrow and Frapping classrooms literature oriented
and skills oriented classes. Concluded that talk surrounding the text or
getting children to think about what was going on in the story were key to
literacy growth.
Styles of Reading aloud:
Co-constructive
Didactic interactional
Performance.
Performance Teachers had higher vocabulary a year
later as kindergarteners,
Found that interactions that occurred as the story
was read that involved both children and teachers and that were analytic in
nature led to positive effects on both vocabulary and story comprehension in
kindergarten. (Analytic) require children to reflect on the story content or
language
Harmful to learning:
Teacher telling too quickly
Children straying off topic
Most effective: encouragement of children’s responses
involves focusing on important story ideas and allowing children opportunities
to reflect rather than expectation a quickly retrieve answer.
Interactive style to be the most effective and the
just reading less effective for vocabulary and comprehension
Learning requires attention to incoming informational
connection of pieces of information and interaction of new information and
prior knowledge
Whitehurst approach (1988) Dialogic reading where
children are to become story-tellers over time. Adult role is to ask open-ended
questions and expand the child’s verbalizations. Numerous studies indicated
dialogic reading enhances expressive language and emergent literacy skills in
children form all socioeconomic status groups even after relatively brief (4
week) interventions.
Talk
Interactional talk requiring attention and response
from the children dovetails strongly wit other current understandings of the
learning process make it clear that successful learning requires more than mere
exposure to information. Rather learning requires attention to incoming
information connection of pieces of informant and integration of new
information and prior knowledge.
Risley
Children’s language depends on their exposure to and
involvement in language with amount of talk being he key to higher language
achievement.
In their home made profound differences in their
language development at age 3 related to their accomplishment in literacy in
school at age 9: positive tone and asking children and giving them choices
rather than telling them.
Build Meaning
Interactional talk requiring attention and response
from the children dovetails strongly with other current understandings about
learning.
- Current understanding: learning requires attention to incoming information, connection of pieces of information, and integration of new information and prior knowledge.
Children’s language learning depends on their
exposure to and involvement in language, with amount of talk being the key to
higher language achievement.
- Number of words spoken in a home showed profound language development by age 3.
- Reciprocal conversational interaction between parent and child per hour was profoundly related to children’s verbal cognitive competence.
Conversations require each partner to say something
related to the shared topic for a conversation to continue.
For children to continue the their role in
conversation children need to listen for vocabulary content and attempt
utterance forms so they can construct responses.
Being part of conversations familiarizes children to
what might be said in the language and prompts them to practice selection what
can be said appropriately in the immediate circumstances.
De-contextualized language underlies literacy
competence; getting children involved in talking about the ideas in stories
they hear. Promoted literacy growth.
Interactive co-constructive talk
Text talk was developed to scaffold children’s
comprehension of a story as the events and ideas unfold. “What is happening
now? What do we know so far about their family? How have things changed?” Talk
text encourages children to articulate their thinking and put together ideas
form the story.
Most often children parrot part of the text that has
just been read.
Follow Up
Teachers need to follow up on questioning to ensure
that children are in the lane and not just on the road of comprehension.
Children understand the relationships and problems in a story.
Children need to be "coax" along at time to
make connections to a story. They must go though a text piece by piece
supporting the children allowing them to make the connections.
Principals Effective Interactions
Teachers need students to connect on more than
surface level easy questions.
*Develop student’s abilities to construct meaning by
interaction with story events and ideas through elaboration.
Repetition of ideas is a characteristic of real
conversation. It is a way of letting our conversation partners know that they
have been heard and lets them know where our next move in the conversation will
go.
Modeling and Pursuing
Teacher gives opportunities to answer question but
when the teacher does not get the correct responses she will then model
how the question should be answered.
Even with sparse answers recasting (pursuing) the
ideas in the question and eventually getting something to develop.
Reread Text as Often as Needed
Going back to text to re-read models for children
that dealing with text is not a linear process, but that in the course of
reading, a reader returns to the text as a resource for building meaning. (Thus
creating readers that will look back checking the text and using that to
develop their ideas.) Rereading portions of text helps children build the
understanding that to successfully comprehend text a reader needs to deal with
what is in the text rather than guess.
Comments:
The gap teachers and students have to overcome is
huge considering so many children are behind by age 3 according to the amount
language exposure and interactive language used in a child’s home.
Teachers will have to work harder to grow children’s
langauage. It will take a great deal of introspective questioning and listening
to answers and redirecting sparse responses to help children explain clearly
their ideas and connections to a story.
One of the most important points I got from this
article is that deep language learning comes from conversation where both
partners are contributing in a meaningful manner. From an educational stance,
it will require a teacher to question, model, and pursue students into deeper
conversation about stories or topics. We can no longer settle for the short
sparse surface answers to a question. We will have listen students and hold
them to a higher level of participation during text conversation. Teachers will
have to really listen in a active way to help children develop their
comprehension and language skills.
I see many things in this article that I will have to
work on in my own classroom. It is difficult to keep them from straying off
topic especially in a book they can relate to their own lives and families. I
don’t want them to feel like I am not interested in their lives and thoughts. It
is like millions of things are running through their little minds and even the
mention of a color will make them think of their dog and they are off chasing
rabbits.
I do feel I have grown tremendously as a teacher in
my questioning, pursuing, and modeling during my reading time. This year my
students have grown and out perform all my classes in earlier years. I feel my
students can answer questions in a deeper more meaningful way.
GUIDED READING: The Romance and the Reality
Irene C. Fountas, Gay Su Pinnell
Summary:
In Guided Reading Groups readers are actively engaged
in the lesson as they learn how to take words apart, flexibly and efficiently,
while attending to the meaning of a text. They begin thinking about the text
before reading, attend to the meaning while reading, and are invited to share
their thinking after reading. They deepen their understanding of a variety of
texts through thoughtful conversation. The teachers have embraced guided
reading, “an instructional context for supporting each reader’s development of
effective strategies for processing novel texts at increasingly challenging
levels of difficulty”.
Roots for Guided Reading came from New Zealand
schools.
Differentiated Instruction
Many teachers have embraced small-group teaching as a
way of effectively teaching the broad range of learners in their classrooms.
Because readers engage with texts within their control (with supportive
teaching), teachers have the opportunity to see students reading books with
proficient processing every day. In addition, it is vital to support students
in taking on more challenging texts so that they can grow as readers, using the
text gradient as a “ladder of progress” (Clay, 1991, p. 215).
Leveled Books
Leveled books are one of the important changes in
Guided Reading. Teachers have learned to collect short texts at the levels they
need and to use the levels as a guide for putting the right book in the hands
of students. The individual titles enable teachers to choose different books
for different groups so that they can design a student’s literacy program and
students can take “different paths to common outcomes” (Clay, 1998).
Benchmark Assessments
Teachers engage in authentic, text-based assessment
conferences that involve students in reading real books as a measure of how
they read. Administered during the first weeks of school, an assessment
conference with a set of carefully leveled texts yields reliable data to guide
teaching.
Running Records
They can code the students’ reading behaviors and
score the records, noting accuracy levels. From that information, they make
decisions about the level that is appropriate for students to read
independently (independent level) and the level at which it would be productive
to begin instruction.
Teachers have learned to avoid the daily struggle
with very difficult material that will not permit smooth, proficient processing
no matter how expert the teaching. Instead, they strive for text selection that
will help students read proficiently and learn more as readers every day,
always with the goal of reading at grade level or above.
Guided Reading attending to elements of proficient
reading: decoding, comprehension, and fluency. Assessment of students’ reading
levels and the teaching that grows out of it go beyond accurate word reading.
In addition to the goal of effective word solving, teachers are concerned about
comprehension of texts.
The reality is that there will be more for everyone
to learn as we move forward. The compelling benefits of guided reading for
students may elude us unless we attend to the teaching decisions that assure
that every student in our care climbs the ladder of success.
To change our practices in an enduring way, we need
to change our understandings. If we bring our old thinking to a new practice,
the rationales may not fit (Wollman, 2007). Teaching practice may often be
enacted in a way that is inconsistent with or even contrary to the underlying
theory that led to its development (Brown & Campione, 1996; Sperling
We address three big areas that
offer new learning in the refinement of teaching in guided reading lessons,
bringing together the romance in guided reading with the reality of its depth.
These areas can be summarized as readers and the reading process, texts, and
teaching.
Thinking Within the Text
The first six systems we categorize as “thinking
within the text.” These activities are solving words, monitoring and
correcting, searching for and using information, summarizing information in a
way that the reader can remember it, adjusting reading for different purposes
and genres, and sustaining fluency.
Thinking Beyond the Text
The next four systems call for “thinking beyond the
text.” They are inferring, synthesizing, making connections, and predicting.
Reading is a transaction between the text and the reader (Rosenblatt, 1994);
that is, the reader constructs unique meanings through integrating background
knowledge, emotions, attitudes, and expectations with the meaning the writer
expresses.
Thinking About the Text
The last two systems represent how the proficient
reader analyzes and critiques the text. Readers hold up the text as an object
that they can look back at and analyze. They notice aspects of the writer’s
craft appreciate language, literary devices such as use of symbolism, how
characters and their development are revealed, beginnings and endings.
Reading Fluency
Fluency means the efficient and effective processing
of meaningful, connected, communicative language. According to Newkirk (2011),
“the fluent reader is demonstrating comprehension, taking cues from the text,
and taking pleasure in finding the right tempo for the text” (p. 1). He hastens
to explain that he does not mean the laborious, word-to-word struggle to read
something that is clearly too hard for the reader. And he says there is no
ideal speed. The speed has to do with the relationship we have with what we
read.
Oral Language
As readers grow more proficient, language still plays
a strong role. The most obvious is the role of the oral vocabulary, which is
extremely important. However, teachers also consider the reader’s grasp of
sentence complexity and the speaker’s understanding of metaphor, simile,
expression, idioms, and other nuances of speech.
Assessment
Good assessment is the foundation for effective teaching.
Assessment in its simplest form means gaining information about the learners
you will teach. The “noticing” teacher tunes in to the individual reader and
observes how the reader works through a text and thinks about how the reading
sounds.
The key to effective teaching is
your ability to make different decisions for different students at different
points in time, honoring the complexity of development. A key concept related
to guided reading is that grouping is dynamic temporary, not static. Teachers group
and regroup students as they gain behavioral evidence of their progress.
To make effective decisions for
readers, you also need an efficient system for ongoing assessment using running
records. A running record using yesterday’s instructional book takes the place
of benchmark assessment with “unseen text.” The running record becomes a useful
tool for assessing the effects of yesterday’s teaching on the reader.
Rather than teaching the level or the book, you
notice and are able to use the behavioral evidence to guide your next teaching
moves. We see this kind of teaching as the “precision teaching”
that makes guided reading lessons powerful. Reading teachers are like
scientists gathering precise data and using it to form hypotheses. For example,
you can use running records or benchmark assessments to:
- Assess the accuracy level
- Assess fluency
- Observe and code oral reading behaviors systematically to note what students do at difficulty or at error and learn how students are solving problems with text
Leveled Text
The appropriate text allows the reader to expand her
reading powers. To become proficient readers, students must experience
successful processing daily. Not only should they be able to read books
independently, building interest, stamina, and fluency; they also need to
tackle harder books that provide the opportunity to grow more skillful as a
reader.
When the entire class is reading the same book on the
same level most of the readers will not be encountering text
that, with teacher support, causes them to expand their reading powers. There
are many reasons for whole-group instruction, and we recommend that it take
place every day in interactive read-aloud or reading mini lessons.
It will be frustrating to select a book and begin to
use it with a group, only to find it is too easy or too difficult to support
learning. Second, when teachers understand the 10 text characteristics that are
used to determine the level, they understand its demands on the reader and
cause it in a more powerful way in teaching.
The ability to analyze texts represents important
teacher knowledge that takes time to develop.
Many teachers of guided reading have spent a great
deal of time analyzing and comparing texts using the 10 characteristics and
have become “quick” analyzers of texts. They match up their understandings with
their knowledge of the students in the group. When they teach a guided reading
lesson, they can plan quickly what they need to say in the introduction and
anticipate key understandings to talk about in the discussion. When you
understand the inner workings of a text, you can introduce it well and guide a
powerful discussion.
Guided reading is much more. It is an instructional
context within which the precise teaching moves and language choices are
related to the behaviors observed, moment by moment, and which guide the reader
to engage in problem solving that expands his or her reading power.
Financial literacy is the cognitive understanding of financial components and skills such as budgeting, investing, borrowing, taxation, and personal financial management. The absence of such skills is referred to as being financially illiterate. So, students are you ready for student finance literacy course & to take the first step towards financial freedom and achieve your dreams? Apply now at The Big Red Group, and brace yourself for this remarkable rollercoaster ride of finances!
ReplyDelete